Guide

How to Replace a Toilet Flush Valve Step by Step

To replace a toilet flush valve, shut off the water, drain the tank, disconnect the supply line, unbolt and lift off the tank, then unscrew the old valve's nut from underneath and install the new valve with a fresh gasket. Reassemble, refill, and check for leaks. If the leak is only at the flapper, a repair that needs no tank removal is faster.

Updated 2026-11-12 · Based on published specifications and maker information

Top picks from our best toilet flush valve comparison

Decide whether you need a full flush valve replacement

The flush valve is the drain assembly at the bottom of the tank. It includes the opening the flapper seals, the overflow tube, and the threaded base that passes through the tank. Most running toilets are fixed with a new flapper and fill valve alone, so check those first.

Replace the whole flush valve when the seat the flapper rests on is cracked, pitted, or corroded, or when the base leaks around the nut. If you want the details on which parts fail most, our best toilet flush valve page compares kits for both repairs.

There is also a shortcut. The Fluidmaster PerforMAX 5 Minute 2in Flush Valve Kit is listed as a peel and stick design with no tank removal and a 5 minute install time. It suits a worn seat on a 2 in valve when the tank is otherwise sound. The steps below cover the full replacement, which is the better route when the base itself is leaking.

Measure the opening and gather supplies

Toilets use one of two flush valve sizes, 2 in or 3 in. Measure the drain opening at the bottom of the tank, or the old flapper, before you buy. Kits are made for one size, so a mismatch means a return trip.

If you are replacing a full flush valve with a gasket system, also pick up a tank-to-bowl gasket and bolt set unless your kit includes one. For example, the Fluidmaster Adjustable 2-in Flush Valve Repair Kit lists gasket bolts, a toilet tool, and a 5 year warranty.

  • New flush valve kit in the right size
  • Tank-to-bowl gasket and bolts, if not included
  • Adjustable wrench or channel-lock pliers
  • Screwdriver
  • Bucket, sponge, and old towels
  • Small cup or wet/dry vacuum for the last of the water
  • Safety glasses and work gloves

Step by step: remove the old flush valve

Wear safety glasses. Rusted bolts can flake or snap, and a slipped tool can crack porcelain.

Work through these steps in order:

  • Turn the shutoff valve on the wall clockwise until it stops.
  • Flush and hold the handle down so the tank empties. Sponge out the remaining water, or use a cup or wet/dry vacuum.
  • Place a towel and bucket under the supply connection, then unscrew the coupling nut that joins the supply line to the fill valve.
  • Inside the tank, hold each tank bolt head with a screwdriver while a wrench loosens the nut under the bowl. Keep going until both or all bolts are off.
  • Lift the tank straight up and set it on a towel on the floor, ideally on its back or side on a padded surface. Porcelain is heavy and breaks easily, so ask for help if you need it.
  • Unscrew the large plastic nut under the tank that holds the flush valve in place. Pull the old valve up and out, and discard the old rubber washer.

Step by step: install the new flush valve and reassemble

Wipe the opening in the tank clean before you start. Old gasket residue or mineral buildup can cause a slow leak that looks like a faulty new part.

Follow your kit instructions, because designs vary. The general order is below.

  • Set the new flush valve into the tank with its rubber washer seated against the inside bottom.
  • Thread on the large nut from underneath. Tighten by hand, then add about a quarter turn with pliers. Overtightening can crack the tank.
  • Place the new tank-to-bowl gasket over the valve outlet, then lower the tank onto the bowl so the bolt holes line up.
  • Install the bolts with their washers and tighten the nuts a little at a time, alternating sides, until the tank sits level and snug.
  • Reconnect the supply line, reattach the flapper and chain, and set the chain with just a little slack.
  • Open the shutoff valve slowly and let the tank fill. Adjust the water level to the mark on the overflow tube.

Test for leaks

Dry the bottom of the tank and the bolt area with a paper towel. Flush several times and look for drips around the nut, the bolts, and the supply connection.

If you see a drip at a bolt, snug that nut slightly. If water appears at the base of the tank, shut off the water and recheck the gasket seating. Do not crank bolts hard, since uneven pressure is how porcelain cracks.

A kit that includes a fill valve can be installed at the same time. For instance, the Fluidmaster 400AKRP10 lists a fill valve height range of 9 to 14 in and a 10 minute install time. Match the fill valve to your tank height, and compare options on our flush valve comparison page before you buy.

Replacing a flush valve on an older toilet

Older toilets can make this job slower. Bolts and nuts may be corroded, and the tank and bowl may have sat together for decades. Spray penetrating oil on the nuts under the bowl and wait before turning them.

If a nut will not move, you may need to cut the bolt with a hacksaw blade. Protect the porcelain with tape and a rag, and wear eye protection. Do not force a wrench that is slipping.

Also expect that the old valve may not match modern parts exactly. Many universal kits are made to fit most 2 in valve toilets. Still, measure first and check that the kit lists your size.

If the porcelain itself is cracked, stained beyond cleaning, or the toilet has a long history of repairs, a repair may not be worth the effort. Our best toilet page can help you compare replacement models.

Quick comparison of repair routes

Here is how the main approaches differ, based on the published specs.

RouteTank removalSizeListed install time
Fluidmaster 555CRP8 flush valve with flapperNo2 in5 min
Fluidmaster 400AKRP10 complete kitNo (fill valve and flapper)2 in10 min
Fluidmaster adjustable flush valve repair kitYes (includes gasket bolts)2 inNot listed
Fluidmaster PerforMAX 3 in fill valve and flapper kitNo3 inNot listed

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need to take the tank off?

No. Replacing only the flapper or fill valve does not require it. Tank removal is needed for a full flush valve swap, unless you use a peel and stick repair kit designed for a worn seat.

Why does my toilet still run after I replace the flapper?

The flush valve seat may be worn or pitted, so the new flapper cannot seal. A chain that is too tight, or a fill valve set too high, can also keep water running.

Can a 2 in kit fit a 3 in toilet?

No. The flapper and valve must match the opening size, so measure first and buy the matching kit.

Can I reuse the old tank bolts?

It is better to use new bolts and a new gasket. Old hardware may be corroded and can leak when reassembled.

Compare the products