Guide

Are Reel Mowers Better? Pros, Cons and Who They Suit

A reel mower is better for some lawns and worse for others. It suits small, fairly flat yards with grass kept short, where its scissor-style cut, light weight and lack of fuel or batteries pay off. If your grass gets tall, your yard is large or uneven, or you want bagging and self-propelled drive, a powered rotary mower is usually the easier choice.

Updated 2026-11-12 · Based on published specifications and maker information

Top picks from our best reel mower comparison

What a reel mower actually does

A reel mower has a spinning cylinder of curved blades. As the cylinder turns, it pushes grass against a fixed bottom blade and shears it, much like a pair of scissors. A rotary mower, by contrast, spins a flat blade at high speed and hits the grass.

The point of a reel mower is simple. You get a clean cut with no engine, no fuel and no battery. Your own pushing power turns the blades. That is why people who want a quiet, low-maintenance mower keep coming back to them.

In our best reel mower comparison, only one product is a true motorless push reel: the LawnMaster LMRM2001. Many cordless mowers show up in similar searches, but they are rotary mowers with a battery. Check the product type before you compare anything else.

The pros of a reel mower

The biggest advantages come from the design. There is less to buy, fuel and repair, and the cut is gentle on the grass.

  • Scissor-like cut: The LawnMaster listing describes a cut with no ripping or tearing of grass blades, which is the main reason people link reel mowers to a healthier lawn.
  • No fuel, no charging: The LawnMaster is motorless, so there are no batteries to charge or replace and no gas or oil to store.
  • Light weight: At 30.2 lb, it is far lighter than the self-propelled models on our page, which run from 63.9 lb to 74.95 lb. That makes it easier to lift, carry and store.
  • Low noise: With no motor, the main sound is the whirring of the blades and wheels. You can still hear your neighbors, and they can hear you less.
  • Simple controls: There is no pull cord, no throttle and no battery gauge. You walk and it cuts.

The cons and limits to know about

Reel mowers ask more of you and of your lawn. These are the drawbacks that matter most.

Height range is the first one. The LawnMaster lists 1.3 to 2.6 in across 9 positions. That works well for grass you mow often, but it is a narrow range. If the grass grows past the top setting, a reel will struggle. The EGO LM2134SP-2 lists 1 to 4 in, which gives more room for overgrown patches.

You also push every foot yourself. There is no drive system, so slopes, thick turf and larger lawns take real effort. A reel works best when you mow on a steady schedule and never let the grass get far ahead of you.

Debris is another weak point. Sticks, acorns and other hard objects can jam or nick the cylinder, so clear the lawn before you start. Reel mowers also tend to leave clippings on the lawn rather than collect them. Our product data lists no grass bag for the LawnMaster, while the SENIX gas model lists a 19 gal bag and the EGO LM2114 lists 18.5 gal.

Finally, the blades need care. The cylinder and bottom blade must stay aligned and sharp for a clean cut. Dull or misaligned blades tear grass instead of shearing it, which cancels the main advantage.

Reel mower vs powered mowers

The table below uses the published specs from our comparison page. It shows how the one true reel stacks up against three powered options.

Cutting width matters because a wider deck needs fewer passes. The LawnMaster's 20 in width is close to the 21 in and 22 in decks on the powered mowers, so you do not give up much coverage. What you give up is drive, bagging and a taller height range.

MowerTypeWidthWeightHeight rangePower and extras
LawnMaster LMRM2001Push reel20 in30.2 lb1.3 to 2.6 in (9 positions)Motorless, 2-year warranty
EGO LM2134SP-2Cordless, self-propelled21 in63.9 lb1 to 4 in (8 positions)Two batteries, up to 100 min runtime
Greenworks MO60L427Cordless, self-propelled25 in67.17 lbNot listedTwo batteries, 70 min runtime
SENIX LSSG-H4Gas, self-propelled22 in72.8 lb1.25 to 4 in (6 positions)170 cc engine, 19 gal bag

Who a reel mower suits

A reel mower is a good match if most of these describe you:

  • Your lawn is small and mostly flat.
  • You mow often enough that the grass stays short.
  • You want to avoid fuel, batteries and engine upkeep.
  • You like a quiet mowing session and do not need a bag.
  • You have a place to store a lighter mower and are willing to keep the blades adjusted.

Who should skip one

Skip the reel if your lawn is large, steep or bumpy, or if the grass often grows well past 2.6 in between mowings. In those cases a powered mower with a taller height range and a drive system will save you effort. The EGO LM2134SP-2, for example, lists self-propelled drive and a 1 to 4 in range.

If you want the widest path, look at powered options. In our reel mower comparison, the Greenworks MO60L427 has the widest deck at 25 in among all 21 products. It is a cordless rotary, not a reel, so you trade the scissor cut for coverage.

Also skip it if you want a bagger or mulching function. Those features show up on powered models in our data, not on the LawnMaster.

Safety notes

Reel blades are sharp even though the mower is motorless. Keep hands and feet away from the cylinder, wear closed shoes, and never reach in to clear a jam while the wheels are turning. Tip the mower or stop it fully before you touch the blades.

If you choose a powered mower instead, remove the battery or disconnect the spark plug before clearing a clog or working near the blade. Rotary mowers can throw stones and debris, so wear eye protection. Gas mowers are loud, so use hearing protection, and only refuel when the engine is off and cool, outdoors and away from flames.

Frequently asked questions

Do reel mowers need sharpening?

Yes. The cylinder and bottom blade stay sharp only if they are kept in good contact and adjusted from time to time. If the mower starts tearing grass or leaving ragged tips, it is time to adjust or sharpen it.

Can a reel mower cut tall or overgrown grass?

Not well. Reel mowers work best on short grass that is mowed often. If the grass is taller than the top height setting, raise the height first or use a powered mower for the first cut.

Are reel mowers hard to push?

They take more effort than a self-propelled mower because there is no drive. The LawnMaster weighs 30.2 lb, which helps, but slopes and thick turf still add work.

Is a cordless mower the same as a reel mower?

No. Most cordless mowers are rotary mowers with a battery and motor. A reel mower is defined by its spinning cylinder that shears grass against a fixed blade.

Compare the products