
Fiskars 384220-1001Fiskars Ergo Garden Trowel
Cast aluminum blade, ergonomic grip, hang hole and a lifetime warranty.
- Blade material
- Cast aluminum
- Weight
- 6.4 oz
- Warranty
- Lifetime*
A good trowel needs a blade that resists rust, a grip that stays comfortable and a build that holds up in hard soil. We put 8 products on one spec sheet and compared blade material, length, weight, handle material, grip shape, rust resistance and warranty. Some products here are not garden trowels at all. The tile and brick trowels solve a different job, so check the type before you buy. Our ranking favors the garden models for this keyword.
Quick answer
Ranked from 8 trowels that met our standard, compared on blade material, ergonomic grip, one-piece construction.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links to retailers on this site are affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Cast aluminum blade, ergonomic grip, hang hole and a lifetime warranty.

Cast aluminum head with an 11 in overall length and a lifetime warranty.

At 13.5 in, it has the longest overall length of the eight products.
| Spec | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best Scoreout of 100 | 80 | 79 | 64 | 62 | 61 | 48 | 45 | 41 |
| Blade material | Cast aluminum | Cast aluminum | Stainless steel (best in row) | Stainless steel (best in row) | Aluminum alloy | Aluminum alloy | Stainless steel (best in row) | Carbon steel |
| Overall lengthin | 12.3 in | 11.0 in | 13.5 in | 11.0 in | 12.4 in | — | 11.0 in | 11.0 in |
| Blade lengthin | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Blade widthin | — | — | — | — | — | — | 4.5 in | 4.9 in |
| Blade thicknessmm | — | — | — | — | 2.0 mm | — | — | — |
| Weightoz | 6.4 oz | 0.3 oz | 0.2 oz (best in row) | 6.3 oz | 6.3 oz | 5.6 oz | — | 16.0 oz |
| Handle material | Plastic | Plastic | ComfortGEL (cushioned) | Hardwood (FSC certified) | TPR rubber | Soft rubber | Rubber | DuraSoft |
| Ergonomic grip | Yes | Yes | Yes | — | Yes | Yes | — | — |
| Rust-resistant | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | — |
| One-piece or welded build | — | — | — | — | — | — | No | Yes (best in row) |
| Hang hole | Yes | Yes | — | Yes | Yes | — | — | — |
| Warrantyyears | Lifetime* (best in row) | Lifetime* (best in row) | — | — | — | Lifetime* (best in row) | 1 year | — |
We reviewed 18 trowels and kept only the 8 that pass every check below. Those are ranked by a Best Score built from spec fit for this job, sales rank.
These reviews are based on specifications and listing information. They cover what each maker publishes and what that means for digging, transplanting and general soil work.
Fiskars Ergo leads our ranking for general digging
The Fiskars Ergo Garden Trowel ranks first on our spec sheet. It has a cast aluminum blade, which the listing says resists rust and adds power in tough soil. For general digging and transplanting, a rust-resistant blade matters because the tool stays in damp dirt and gets rinsed often. Aluminum is also the material the listing credits for staying sharp through heavy use.
The plastic handle has an ergonomic shape. The listing says it gives more control and reduces fatigue. That helps when you dig many holes in one session. That matters for hard soil, where you push hard on the grip. At 12.25 in long and 6.4 oz, it is a mid-length tool. The maker does not publish blade width or blade thickness.
It also has a hang hole for storage and a lifetime warranty. Only three of the eight products on the page list a lifetime warranty, so that is a real point in its favor. Anyone who wants a dependable all-purpose trowel can start here.
VerdictA rust-resistant, ergonomic trowel with a lifetime warranty, and the best fit for this keyword.
Fiskars FiberComp: a shorter, near-twin of the leader
The Fiskars FiberComp Hand Trowel ranks second. It uses the same cast aluminum blade material as the leader, and the listing calls the head oversized for digging in tough soil quickly. A larger head moves more dirt per scoop, which suits filling pots and planting holes. The rust-resistant rating covers wet garden work.
Overall length is 11 in, which is shorter than the first-ranked trowel. That makes it easier to use in tight beds and containers. The handle is plastic with an ergonomic grip, and the listing describes a lightweight FiberComp design. The listed weight figure of 0.32 oz looks unusually low for a trowel, so check it before relying on it.
It has a hang hole and a lifetime warranty, the same as the leader. The maker does not publish blade width or thickness. Between the two Fiskars models, the Ergo is longer and the FiberComp is shorter, so pick by the reach you want. Choose it if you like a compact tool with a big head.
VerdictA close second that trades some length for a larger head and the same warranty.
Corona ComfortGEL offers the longest reach on the page
The Corona ComfortGEL Garden Trowel ranks third. Its stainless steel blade is rust-resistant, and the listing says it releases soil smoothly. At 13.5 in, it has the longest overall length of the eight products. A longer tool gives more reach in raised beds and more leverage when you plant and transplant.
The handle is cushioned ComfortGEL with an ergonomic shape. The listing calls it non-slip and says it reduces hand fatigue. That helps if you garden for long stretches. A soft grip also helps when the soil is hard and you press hard. The data lists a weight of 0.16 oz, the lowest among the models that list it, but that looks too low for a steel trowel, so treat it with care.
The data lists no hang hole and no warranty, and the maker does not publish blade width or thickness. Those gaps matter if you want to hang the tool or want written coverage. It suits comfort and reach better than proof of durability.
VerdictA comfortable, long-reach stainless trowel, held back by missing warranty and storage details.
WORKPRO pairs a stainless blade with a hardwood handle
The WORKPRO Garden Hand Trowel ranks fourth. The blade is stainless steel, and the listing calls it polished and highly resistant to rust and corrosion. That suits a tool that sits in wet soil. The handle is FSC certified hardwood, a different feel from the plastic and rubber grips on the aluminum models.
It is 11 in long and weighs 6.3 oz. The listing says that size makes it easy to store, and it has a hang hole and a lanyard. The data does not mark an ergonomic grip, so comfort depends on how you like wood. The listing says the handle is meant to reduce fatigue and ease wrist movement.
It has no warranty listed, and the maker does not publish blade width or thickness. Its stainless blade matches the Corona on material. It is a fair fit for the keyword, since rust resistance is the main need. Choose it if you prefer a wood handle and a stainless blade for routine digging, weeding and transplanting.
VerdictA stainless and hardwood trowel for routine beds, with fewer comfort and coverage details than the leaders.
MECHEER is the only one with a listed blade thickness
The MECHEER Garden Hand Trowel ranks fifth. It is the only trowel on this page that lists blade thickness, at 2.03 mm. Blade thickness tells you how much the blade resists bending in hard soil. The blade is aluminum alloy, and the listing calls the polished head rustproof and easy to clean.
The handle is TPR rubber with an ergonomic, non-slip shape. At 12.4 in long and 6.35 oz, it sits close to the Fiskars Ergo in size and weight. It also has a hang hole, and the listing says a rope fits through it. The listing also says it is light enough to carry in a garden bag.
The data lists no warranty, and the maker does not publish blade width. It also ranks below the Fiskars and Corona models on our spec score. The rustproof label is the listing's claim. It is a reasonable choice for general digging, weeding and transplanting if you want a thickness figure on the sheet.
VerdictA well-documented aluminum trowel with a thickness figure, but no warranty to back it.
Best among the reviewed tools
Stainless steel and aluminum both resist rust, which matters because a trowel lives in wet soil. Carbon steel, as on the brick trowel here, is made for masonry, not soil. Check that the maker states rust resistance, then rinse and dry the blade after use.
An ergonomic or cushioned grip cuts hand fatigue when you dig for a long stretch. Rubber, TPR and gel grips add cushion. Plastic and wood are firmer. If you have sore hands or garden often, put the grip first. A hang hole is a small extra that helps storage.
Overall length runs from 11 in to 13.5 in on this page. Longer tools give more reach in raised beds. Shorter ones fit pots and tight spots. Blade thickness is listed for only one model, so check whether a maker publishes it if hard, rocky soil is your main job.
Three products here list a lifetime warranty. Others list one year or none. Some makers do not publish whether the blade is one piece or welded, so that detail is often unknown. A written warranty is a useful sign a maker expects the tool to last.
Stainless steel and aluminum both resist rust, so either suits general digging. Stainless steel is used on the Corona and WORKPRO models here. Cast aluminum is used on both Fiskars models, which rank first and second on our spec sheet.
Not always. A longer tool, such as the 13.5 in Corona, gives more reach and leverage in raised beds. A shorter one, such as the 11 in FiberComp, is easier to use in pots and tight beds. Pick the length that matches where you plant.
It is not a good fit. The QEP is a notched trowel for tile, and the MARSHALLTOWN is a brick trowel forged from carbon steel. Both are built for setting material, not digging or transplanting, so choose a garden trowel for soil work.
Three products list a lifetime warranty: the Fiskars Ergo, the Fiskars FiberComp and the Edward Tools transplanter. The Corona, WORKPRO and MECHEER models do not list a warranty in our data, so check the seller if coverage matters to you.
Your own selection is kept in the link, so friends see the same side-by-side.