Paint Trays · 6 compared side by side

Best Paint Trays in 2027

A good paint tray holds enough paint for the job, stays put while you work, and cleans up fast. Start with roller size, since a 4 in tray and a 9 in tray do different jobs. Then check the liner count, whether liners are reusable, and features like a non-slip base, textured ramp and pour spout. Capacity and weight also matter for bigger jobs. We put 6 products on one spec sheet so you can compare them line by line.

Quick answer

Ranked from 6 paint trays that met our standard, compared on capacity, reusable liners, non-slip base.

Updated November 202613 reviewed · 6 met our standard13 specs comparedBy Comparabo editors

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links to retailers on this site are affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Top picks

Best overall
#1
Mister Rui 4 inch paint tray with liner 10 pcs

Mister Rui 4 inch paint tray with liner 10 pcsMister Rui 4in Paint Tray Set 21-Pack

Lists a non-slip base, magnetic holder, pour spout and 20 reusable liners for small-roller jobs.

Roller size
4 in
Liners included
20
Tray material
Plastic
Check price on Amazon
Metal tray for 9 in rollers
#2
Bates Choice QBAI020B408

Bates Choice QBAI020B408Bates 9 Inch Paint Tray Liners - 21 pcs, One Metal Tray with 20 Plastic Liners

Fits 9 in rollers and comes with 20 liners for quick color changes.

Roller size
9 in
Liners included
20
Tray material
Metal
Check price on Amazon
Roller frame included
#3
Voomey A03012

Voomey A03012Voomey 4 Inch Paint Tray Set

The only set on this page that lists a roller frame in the box, plus a pour spout.

Roller size
4 in
Liners included
12
Tray material
Plastic
Check price on Amazon

Comparison table

Swipe or scroll sideways to see every model.
Top 6 paint trays
Spec
#1
Mister Rui 4 inch paint tray with liner 10 pcs
Best overallCheck price on Amazon
#2
Bates Choice QBAI020B408
Metal tray for 9 in rollersCheck price on Amazon
#3
Voomey A03012
Roller frame includedCheck price on Amazon
#4
Mister Rui 9 inch paint tray with liner
Largest tray footprintCheck price on Amazon
#5
Mister Rui 04OPTL
Simple trim trayCheck price on Amazon
#6
Bates Choice SFGP010B403
Lightest in the lineupCheck price on Amazon
Best Scoreout of 100855544353028
Roller sizein4 in9 in4 in9 in4 in4 in
Tray materialPlasticMetal (best in row)PlasticPlasticPlasticPlastic
Paint capacityqt0.53 qt—————
Trays included1 1 1 1 1 1
Liners included20 (best in row)20 (best in row)12 15 10 10
Reusable linersYes (best in row)NoNoNoNoNo
Roller frame included—NoYes (best in row)—NoNo
Magnetic brush holderYes—————
Textured ramp———Yes——
Non-slip baseYes——Yes——
Pour spoutYes—Yes———
Tray lengthin13.0 in—4.0 in17.4 in11.5 in—
Weightlb1.65 lb2.60 lb—1.00 lb0.66 lb0.57 lb (best in row)
Best in row— not published by the maker yet

How we chose

We reviewed 13 paint trays and kept only the 6 that pass every check below. Those are ranked by a Best Score built from spec fit for this job, sales rank.

Read the full method

In-depth reviews

These reviews are based on specifications and listing information. Each one looks at what the listed specs mean for a paint job of a given size.

Best overall

Mister Rui 4 inch paint tray with liner 10 pcsMister Rui 4in Paint Tray Set 21-Pack

A 4-in tray built for trim and touch-ups

Roller size
4 in
Tray material
Plastic
Liners included
20 (best of the reviewed tools)
Paint capacity
0.53 qt

This set suits small rollers. The tray fits a 4 in roller and holds 0.53 qt of paint. That is enough for trim, doors and touch-ups, but not for a whole room. The tray is plastic and weighs 1.65 lb. It is 13 in long, so it stays easy to carry and store.

Staying put matters when you work on a ladder or a smooth floor. The listing says the tray has a non-slip base. It also has a built-in magnetic brush holder and a pour spout. Both help on a tight work surface. The holder keeps a brush from resting in the paint. The spout lets you pour extra paint back into the can.

Cleanup is the other half of the job. The set comes with 20 liners, and the spec sheet marks them as reusable. That ties for the highest liner count on the page. Liners also protect the tray from dried paint. The set leads our ranking.

Pros

  • Non-slip base
  • Magnetic brush holder
  • 20 reusable liners

Cons

  • Holds only 0.53 qt
  • Too small for wall rolling
Buy it if
you paint trim, doors or small touch-ups.
Skip it if
you roll full walls with a 9 in roller.

VerdictIt earns the top rank by pairing a stable base with 20 liners for small jobs.

Metal tray for 9 in rollers

Bates Choice QBAI020B408Bates 9 Inch Paint Tray Liners - 21 pcs, One Metal Tray with 20 Plastic Liners

A sturdy metal 9 in tray with 20 liners

Roller size
9 in (best of the reviewed tools)
Tray material
Metal (best of the reviewed tools)
Liners included
20 (best of the reviewed tools)
Paint capacity
—

Metal is the main draw here. The tray is made of metal and fits a 9 in roller, a size suited to larger surfaces. It weighs 2.6 lb, the heaviest among the models that list weight. A heavier tray may feel steadier, though the maker doesn't publish whether it has a non-slip base.

The set includes 20 liners, tied for the most on the page. They are disposable, and the spec sheet says they are not reusable. Liners keep paint off the metal, so you can change colors fast and toss the liner when you finish. The listing says the tray and liners have a textured surface for even roller loading.

Gaps matter too. The maker doesn't publish capacity or a pour spout, and no roller frame is included. If you need a frame, you must buy one separately. For wall painting with quick cleanup, the tray still fits the job, and it ranks second on our list.

Pros

  • Metal tray for 9 in rollers
  • 20 liners included
  • Textured tray and liners

Cons

  • Roller frame not included
  • Liners are not reusable
Buy it if
you roll walls and want a metal tray.
Skip it if
you want a lightweight tray or a pour spout.

VerdictA sturdy metal 9 in tray with plenty of liners, but few extras listed.

Roller frame included

Voomey A03012Voomey 4 Inch Paint Tray Set

A 4 in set that includes the roller frame

Roller size
4 in
Tray material
Plastic
Liners included
12
Paint capacity
—

Voomey is the only set on this page that lists a roller frame as included. The tray is plastic and made for a 4 in roller. The listing points to trim, doors, cabinets and touch-ups. If you don't own a small roller yet, one box covers the basics. It ranks third on our list.

The tray has a pour spout and double-scale markings, which help you measure paint and pour it back with less mess. The markings let you check how much paint is in the tray. The grid design helps load the roller evenly. The data lists a tray length of 4 in, the shortest among the four models that list length, so expect a very compact tray.

It comes with 12 liners, and the data marks them as single use. That is fewer than the 20 in two other sets and more than the 10 in two others. Capacity, weight and a non-slip base are not published.

Pros

  • Roller frame included
  • Pour spout and scale markings
  • 12 disposable liners

Cons

  • Liners can't be reused
  • No capacity or weight listed
Buy it if
you need a roller frame in the box.
Skip it if
you need a tray for large wall jobs.

VerdictA compact starter set for small jobs that saves you buying a separate frame.

Largest tray footprint

Mister Rui 9 inch paint tray with linerMister Rui 9 Inch Paint Tray Set

A full-size 9 in tray with a roomy footprint

Roller size
9 in (best of the reviewed tools)
Tray material
Plastic
Liners included
15
Paint capacity
—

This is the longest tray in the group. The data lists 17.4 in of length, the highest of the four models that list it, and a 9 in roller size. Weight is 1 lb. A larger plastic tray gives a big roller room to load, and at 1 lb it is easy to move.

Stability and loading both get attention in the specs. The tray has a textured ramp for spreading paint on the roller. It also has a non-slip base, which keeps the tray from sliding while you reach for the next stroke. That matters on stairs or uneven floors. The listing mentions a ribbed incline and non-slip legs.

You get 15 liners and 2 protective covers. The liners are listed as not reusable, so plan on tossing each one. The covers are meant to keep paint from skinning over between coats. The maker doesn't publish capacity or a roller frame. It ranks fourth on our list.

Pros

  • Longest tray at 17.4 in
  • Non-slip base
  • Textured ramp

Cons

  • No roller frame listed
  • Single-use liners
Buy it if
you roll walls and want a roomy plastic tray.
Skip it if
you only paint trim with a 4 in roller.

VerdictA good full-size plastic option for wall work with stable footing and covers for breaks.

Simple trim tray

Mister Rui 04OPTLMister Rui 4 Inch Paint Tray with Liners

A plain 4 in tray for small, quick jobs

Roller size
4 in
Tray material
Plastic
Liners included
10
Paint capacity
—

This tray is built for a 4 in roller. It is plastic, 11.5 in long and weighs 0.66 lb. That makes it light and easy to tuck into a bag. It suits trim and small touch-ups. The listing says the depth can hold plenty of paint, but the maker doesn't publish a capacity figure in quarts.

Cleanup comes from the 10 liners. They are transparent and disposable, and the data marks them as not reusable. Because they are transparent, you can see the paint color you loaded. Swapping a liner lets you change colors and protects the tray from stains. The listing says the liners can also be used on their own.

Extras are thin. The data does not list a pour spout or a non-slip base, and no roller frame is included. The listing mentions a textured design. It ranks fifth on our list. Think of it as a simple add-on rather than a complete kit.

Pros

  • Light at 0.66 lb
  • 10 transparent liners
  • Textured design

Cons

  • No frame in the box
  • Few extras listed
Buy it if
you need a basic tray for trim work.
Skip it if
you want a non-slip base or a pour spout.

VerdictIt does the basics for small trim jobs, but other sets add more features.

Best among the reviewed tools

Buying guide

Match tray to roller size

Pick the tray that fits your roller. A 4 in tray suits trim, doors and touch-ups. A 9 in tray suits walls and ceilings. A tray that is too small makes loading awkward, and one that is too big wastes space and paint on a small job.

Count the liners

Liners are what make cleanup quick. Lift out the used liner and drop in a fresh one to change colors. Check how many come in the set and whether they are reusable. In this lineup, two sets include 20 liners and two include 10.

Look for stability features

A tray that slides or tips costs you paint and time. A non-slip base helps on smooth floors. A pour spout helps return extra paint to the can. A magnetic holder keeps a brush out of the paint. Only some sets in this lineup list these features.

Check capacity and weight

Capacity tells you how long you can roll before a refill. Only one set here lists it, at 0.53 qt. Weight shows how easy a tray is to carry. Among the five that list it, weights run from 0.57 lb to 2.6 lb. Missing specs mean you should read the listing closely.

FAQ

What size paint tray do I need?

Match the tray to your roller. A 4 in tray works with a 4 in roller for trim, doors and cabinets. A 9 in tray works with a 9 in roller for walls and ceilings. Two sets here fit 9 in rollers and four fit 4 in.

Are paint tray liners worth it?

Liners save cleanup time. You lift out the liner when you finish or want a new color, and the tray stays clean. They add a little waste, though. Check whether the set lists reusable liners. Only one set here does, the top-ranked Mister Rui 4 in set.

Is a metal or plastic paint tray better?

Metal is heavier. The metal Bates set here weighs 2.6 lb, and its listing calls it sturdy. Plastic sets that list weight run from 0.57 lb to 1.65 lb, so they are easier to carry. Either type works with liners. Pick based on weight and the features you want.

What keeps a paint tray from sliding?

Look for a non-slip base. Two sets in this lineup list one: the Mister Rui 4 in 21-pack set and the Mister Rui 9 in set. The other sets do not publish this spec, so a stable surface matters more with them.

Related comparisons

Share this comparison

Your own selection is kept in the link, so friends see the same side-by-side.

Top pick · #1Mister Rui 4 inch paint tray with liner 10 pcs
Check price on Amazon